Jump to content


Photo
- - - - -

Cooper's Hawk or Sharp-Shinned?


  • Please log in to reply
21 replies to this topic

#1 BirdMan0325

BirdMan0325

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1025 posts
  • LocationBeavercreek, OH

Posted 07 February 2013 - 03:35 PM

At Spring Grove Cemetery in Cincinnati 02/04 - I'm seeing Sharp-Shinned, but I figure it will be another Cooper's...

A little help?


Coop or Sharp 1


Coop or Sharp 2

Life List - 185; Year - 185
Backyard List - 48 - Northern Waterthrush, Blue-Gray Gnatcatcher, Yellow Warbler (May 7, 2013)
States: Ohio - 183; Indiana - 83; Michigan - 11; Tennessee - 6
Latest lifers: Red Phalarope (May 14, 2013) Eastern Wood-Pewee (May 15, 2013), Western Sandpiper (thanks Amber!), Dickcissel (May 18, 2013)
My photos on Flicker


#2 Derek Elsinger

Derek Elsinger

    Derek Elsinger

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 473 posts

Posted 07 February 2013 - 03:42 PM

Cooper's, I like the big head and long-tailed look. I think you can see a pale nape in one photo.

#3 psweet

psweet

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 6884 posts
  • LocationNortheast Illinois

Posted 07 February 2013 - 04:06 PM

Cooper's seconded.

#4 BirdMan0325

BirdMan0325

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1025 posts
  • LocationBeavercreek, OH

Posted 07 February 2013 - 04:55 PM

Drats!!

Life List - 185; Year - 185
Backyard List - 48 - Northern Waterthrush, Blue-Gray Gnatcatcher, Yellow Warbler (May 7, 2013)
States: Ohio - 183; Indiana - 83; Michigan - 11; Tennessee - 6
Latest lifers: Red Phalarope (May 14, 2013) Eastern Wood-Pewee (May 15, 2013), Western Sandpiper (thanks Amber!), Dickcissel (May 18, 2013)
My photos on Flicker


#5 cany

cany

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1970 posts
  • LocationSo. Cal. Foothills, Cleveland Ntl. Forest

Posted 07 February 2013 - 05:02 PM

Cooper's seconded.


PSweet, what in those photos do you see to pos ID the Cooper's? It was my guess too, but just a guess.

I eliminated RT and RS and came to Cooper's or Sharpie due to tail length, and while the hawk does look greyish back and head, that's as far as I got with those last two things uncertain. Trying to learn:)
New Birder January 1, 2013
Life list: 176

Swainson's thrush, Red-throated loon, Clapper rail, Warbling vireo, Gray flycatcher, MacGullivray's warbler, Western wood-pewee, Reddish egret, Least tern, California gnatcatcher, Peregrine falcon, Black skimmer, Long-billed curlew, Semipalmated plover, Dunlin, Black-bellied plover, Red-breasted merganser, Cliff swallow, Great horned owl, Blue grosbeak, Yellow-breasted chat, Bell's vireo, Lazuli bunting, Black-chinned hummingbird, Green heron, Nashville warbler, Townsend's warbler, Black-throated gray warbler, Ross's goose, Horned grebe, Marbled godwit, Forester's tern, Brant, Western tanager, Bullock's oriole, Yellow warbler, Barn swallow, Brewer's blackbird, Brown-headed cowbird, Ash-throated flycatcher, Ruby-crowned kinglet, Black-headed grosbeak, Willet, California gull, Western gull, Ring-billed gull, Heermann's gull, Brown pelican, Red-throated loon, Royal tern, Elegant tern, Least sandpiper, Sanderling, Whimbrel, Redhead duck, Greater scaup, Western sandpiper, Least bittern, White-faced ibis, Blue-winged teal, Greater white-fronted goose, Golden eagle, Zone-tailed hawk, Rufous-crowned sparrow, Sharp-shinned hawk, Common ground-dove, Black-throated green warbler (continuing bird), Wilson's warbler, Common yellowthroat, House wren, Chipping sparrow, Hooded oriole, House sparrow, Song sparrow, Cactus wren, Western kingbird, Red-breasted sapsucker, Downey woodpecker, Bullock's oriole, Common poorwill, American robin, Cooper's hawk, Dowitcher sp., Red-winged blackbird, Greater yellowlegs, Common gallinule, Gadwell, Black-neck stilt, Cinnamon teal, American avocet, Cassin's kingbird, Lark sparrow, Killdeer, Pine siskin, Spotted sandpiper, Egyptian goose, Northern shoveler, Hooded merganser, Canada goose, American goldfinch, Lesser scaup

Having a blast!

#6 psweet

psweet

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 6884 posts
  • LocationNortheast Illinois

Posted 07 February 2013 - 05:04 PM

I was going mostly on what I could see of the face pattern.

#7 cany

cany

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1970 posts
  • LocationSo. Cal. Foothills, Cleveland Ntl. Forest

Posted 07 February 2013 - 05:39 PM

I was going mostly on what I could see of the face pattern.


Thanks:)
New Birder January 1, 2013
Life list: 176

Swainson's thrush, Red-throated loon, Clapper rail, Warbling vireo, Gray flycatcher, MacGullivray's warbler, Western wood-pewee, Reddish egret, Least tern, California gnatcatcher, Peregrine falcon, Black skimmer, Long-billed curlew, Semipalmated plover, Dunlin, Black-bellied plover, Red-breasted merganser, Cliff swallow, Great horned owl, Blue grosbeak, Yellow-breasted chat, Bell's vireo, Lazuli bunting, Black-chinned hummingbird, Green heron, Nashville warbler, Townsend's warbler, Black-throated gray warbler, Ross's goose, Horned grebe, Marbled godwit, Forester's tern, Brant, Western tanager, Bullock's oriole, Yellow warbler, Barn swallow, Brewer's blackbird, Brown-headed cowbird, Ash-throated flycatcher, Ruby-crowned kinglet, Black-headed grosbeak, Willet, California gull, Western gull, Ring-billed gull, Heermann's gull, Brown pelican, Red-throated loon, Royal tern, Elegant tern, Least sandpiper, Sanderling, Whimbrel, Redhead duck, Greater scaup, Western sandpiper, Least bittern, White-faced ibis, Blue-winged teal, Greater white-fronted goose, Golden eagle, Zone-tailed hawk, Rufous-crowned sparrow, Sharp-shinned hawk, Common ground-dove, Black-throated green warbler (continuing bird), Wilson's warbler, Common yellowthroat, House wren, Chipping sparrow, Hooded oriole, House sparrow, Song sparrow, Cactus wren, Western kingbird, Red-breasted sapsucker, Downey woodpecker, Bullock's oriole, Common poorwill, American robin, Cooper's hawk, Dowitcher sp., Red-winged blackbird, Greater yellowlegs, Common gallinule, Gadwell, Black-neck stilt, Cinnamon teal, American avocet, Cassin's kingbird, Lark sparrow, Killdeer, Pine siskin, Spotted sandpiper, Egyptian goose, Northern shoveler, Hooded merganser, Canada goose, American goldfinch, Lesser scaup

Having a blast!

#8 cany

cany

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1970 posts
  • LocationSo. Cal. Foothills, Cleveland Ntl. Forest

Posted 07 February 2013 - 05:42 PM

Cooper's, I like the big head and long-tailed look. I think you can see a pale nape in one photo.


It seems like the tail is almost as long as the body:) The shape is something different for me than the hawks I usually see. The sharpies and coops are harder for me.
New Birder January 1, 2013
Life list: 176

Swainson's thrush, Red-throated loon, Clapper rail, Warbling vireo, Gray flycatcher, MacGullivray's warbler, Western wood-pewee, Reddish egret, Least tern, California gnatcatcher, Peregrine falcon, Black skimmer, Long-billed curlew, Semipalmated plover, Dunlin, Black-bellied plover, Red-breasted merganser, Cliff swallow, Great horned owl, Blue grosbeak, Yellow-breasted chat, Bell's vireo, Lazuli bunting, Black-chinned hummingbird, Green heron, Nashville warbler, Townsend's warbler, Black-throated gray warbler, Ross's goose, Horned grebe, Marbled godwit, Forester's tern, Brant, Western tanager, Bullock's oriole, Yellow warbler, Barn swallow, Brewer's blackbird, Brown-headed cowbird, Ash-throated flycatcher, Ruby-crowned kinglet, Black-headed grosbeak, Willet, California gull, Western gull, Ring-billed gull, Heermann's gull, Brown pelican, Red-throated loon, Royal tern, Elegant tern, Least sandpiper, Sanderling, Whimbrel, Redhead duck, Greater scaup, Western sandpiper, Least bittern, White-faced ibis, Blue-winged teal, Greater white-fronted goose, Golden eagle, Zone-tailed hawk, Rufous-crowned sparrow, Sharp-shinned hawk, Common ground-dove, Black-throated green warbler (continuing bird), Wilson's warbler, Common yellowthroat, House wren, Chipping sparrow, Hooded oriole, House sparrow, Song sparrow, Cactus wren, Western kingbird, Red-breasted sapsucker, Downey woodpecker, Bullock's oriole, Common poorwill, American robin, Cooper's hawk, Dowitcher sp., Red-winged blackbird, Greater yellowlegs, Common gallinule, Gadwell, Black-neck stilt, Cinnamon teal, American avocet, Cassin's kingbird, Lark sparrow, Killdeer, Pine siskin, Spotted sandpiper, Egyptian goose, Northern shoveler, Hooded merganser, Canada goose, American goldfinch, Lesser scaup

Having a blast!

#9 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 05:57 PM

wow, i see pale nape in top picture and very thin legs in the second.. is this the same bird?

#10 BirdMan0325

BirdMan0325

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1025 posts
  • LocationBeavercreek, OH

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:17 PM

The legs are what made me think sharp. The bird standing on the ground was taken first (through snowy windshield. I watched it fly to a tree and then drove as close to the tree as I could for the second photo.

Life List - 185; Year - 185
Backyard List - 48 - Northern Waterthrush, Blue-Gray Gnatcatcher, Yellow Warbler (May 7, 2013)
States: Ohio - 183; Indiana - 83; Michigan - 11; Tennessee - 6
Latest lifers: Red Phalarope (May 14, 2013) Eastern Wood-Pewee (May 15, 2013), Western Sandpiper (thanks Amber!), Dickcissel (May 18, 2013)
My photos on Flicker


#11 TheBillyPilgrim

TheBillyPilgrim

    Frank

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 6747 posts
  • LocationCollege Park, MD

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:35 PM

I'd be careful using that thin leg character from a single photo. These guys have laterally compressed tarsi and both species can look very thin, depending on the angle. Additionally, it's a rather relative/subjective character if you don't have another bird to compare it against. I agree with Cooper's Hawk for this bird.
Life List: 560

Latest birds: Purple Sandpiper, Ross's Goose, White-winged Crossbill,

2013: 362 species

My Flickr
eBird

Costa Rica Trip Report: http://www.whatbird....rt/#entry396425

#12 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:36 PM

im not sure what lateral compressed tarsi is..but the nape screams coopers, legs say sharpie. i guess its the angle of the photo.

#13 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:40 PM

i just googled. i came up with stuff i have no idea what they are talking about...lol

#14 psweet

psweet

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 6884 posts
  • LocationNortheast Illinois

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:40 PM

Tarsi refer to the lower part of a bird's leg (which is actually analogous to the long bones in our feet). Laterally compressed means that they are thinner from left to right than they are front to back. In a photo like this, I would also be careful using that feature because it's common for a white background to bleed around a thin object like a bird's leg, which will make it look thinner.

#15 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:43 PM

oh ok, ty psweet. you explained it very well :). yes, pale nape makes it a coopers.

#16 ololaiki

ololaiki

    ololaiki

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 811 posts
  • LocationSammamish, WA

Posted 07 February 2013 - 06:55 PM

Tarsi refer to the lower part of a bird's leg (which is actually analogous to the long bones in our feet). Laterally compressed means that they are thinner from left to right than they are front to back. In a photo like this, I would also be careful using that feature because it's common for a white background to bleed around a thin object like a bird's leg, which will make it look thinner.


Wow! Short paragraph and so much information. Thank you psweet!

#17 cany

cany

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1970 posts
  • LocationSo. Cal. Foothills, Cleveland Ntl. Forest

Posted 07 February 2013 - 07:24 PM

Tarsi refer to the lower part of a bird's leg (which is actually analogous to the long bones in our feet). Laterally compressed means that they are thinner from left to right than they are front to back. In a photo like this, I would also be careful using that feature because it's common for a white background to bleed around a thin object like a bird's leg, which will make it look thinner.


Thank heavens I took a year of zoology years ago:) I still remember a lot of it and while it's different in birds than mammals, a lot is similar. It really helps.
New Birder January 1, 2013
Life list: 176

Swainson's thrush, Red-throated loon, Clapper rail, Warbling vireo, Gray flycatcher, MacGullivray's warbler, Western wood-pewee, Reddish egret, Least tern, California gnatcatcher, Peregrine falcon, Black skimmer, Long-billed curlew, Semipalmated plover, Dunlin, Black-bellied plover, Red-breasted merganser, Cliff swallow, Great horned owl, Blue grosbeak, Yellow-breasted chat, Bell's vireo, Lazuli bunting, Black-chinned hummingbird, Green heron, Nashville warbler, Townsend's warbler, Black-throated gray warbler, Ross's goose, Horned grebe, Marbled godwit, Forester's tern, Brant, Western tanager, Bullock's oriole, Yellow warbler, Barn swallow, Brewer's blackbird, Brown-headed cowbird, Ash-throated flycatcher, Ruby-crowned kinglet, Black-headed grosbeak, Willet, California gull, Western gull, Ring-billed gull, Heermann's gull, Brown pelican, Red-throated loon, Royal tern, Elegant tern, Least sandpiper, Sanderling, Whimbrel, Redhead duck, Greater scaup, Western sandpiper, Least bittern, White-faced ibis, Blue-winged teal, Greater white-fronted goose, Golden eagle, Zone-tailed hawk, Rufous-crowned sparrow, Sharp-shinned hawk, Common ground-dove, Black-throated green warbler (continuing bird), Wilson's warbler, Common yellowthroat, House wren, Chipping sparrow, Hooded oriole, House sparrow, Song sparrow, Cactus wren, Western kingbird, Red-breasted sapsucker, Downey woodpecker, Bullock's oriole, Common poorwill, American robin, Cooper's hawk, Dowitcher sp., Red-winged blackbird, Greater yellowlegs, Common gallinule, Gadwell, Black-neck stilt, Cinnamon teal, American avocet, Cassin's kingbird, Lark sparrow, Killdeer, Pine siskin, Spotted sandpiper, Egyptian goose, Northern shoveler, Hooded merganser, Canada goose, American goldfinch, Lesser scaup

Having a blast!

#18 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 07:45 PM

my dad taught zoology, psysiology and anatomy for years in college. i should know more about that kind of stuff but i dont.lol

#19 cany

cany

    Advanced Member

  • New Members
  • PipPipPip
  • 1970 posts
  • LocationSo. Cal. Foothills, Cleveland Ntl. Forest

Posted 07 February 2013 - 07:54 PM

my dad taught zoology, psysiology and anatomy for years in college. i should know more about that kind of stuff but i dont.lol


Who knows! If it was local, maybe I took classes from him:)
New Birder January 1, 2013
Life list: 176

Swainson's thrush, Red-throated loon, Clapper rail, Warbling vireo, Gray flycatcher, MacGullivray's warbler, Western wood-pewee, Reddish egret, Least tern, California gnatcatcher, Peregrine falcon, Black skimmer, Long-billed curlew, Semipalmated plover, Dunlin, Black-bellied plover, Red-breasted merganser, Cliff swallow, Great horned owl, Blue grosbeak, Yellow-breasted chat, Bell's vireo, Lazuli bunting, Black-chinned hummingbird, Green heron, Nashville warbler, Townsend's warbler, Black-throated gray warbler, Ross's goose, Horned grebe, Marbled godwit, Forester's tern, Brant, Western tanager, Bullock's oriole, Yellow warbler, Barn swallow, Brewer's blackbird, Brown-headed cowbird, Ash-throated flycatcher, Ruby-crowned kinglet, Black-headed grosbeak, Willet, California gull, Western gull, Ring-billed gull, Heermann's gull, Brown pelican, Red-throated loon, Royal tern, Elegant tern, Least sandpiper, Sanderling, Whimbrel, Redhead duck, Greater scaup, Western sandpiper, Least bittern, White-faced ibis, Blue-winged teal, Greater white-fronted goose, Golden eagle, Zone-tailed hawk, Rufous-crowned sparrow, Sharp-shinned hawk, Common ground-dove, Black-throated green warbler (continuing bird), Wilson's warbler, Common yellowthroat, House wren, Chipping sparrow, Hooded oriole, House sparrow, Song sparrow, Cactus wren, Western kingbird, Red-breasted sapsucker, Downey woodpecker, Bullock's oriole, Common poorwill, American robin, Cooper's hawk, Dowitcher sp., Red-winged blackbird, Greater yellowlegs, Common gallinule, Gadwell, Black-neck stilt, Cinnamon teal, American avocet, Cassin's kingbird, Lark sparrow, Killdeer, Pine siskin, Spotted sandpiper, Egyptian goose, Northern shoveler, Hooded merganser, Canada goose, American goldfinch, Lesser scaup

Having a blast!

#20 Guest_Birdluvr_*

Guest_Birdluvr_*
  • Guests

Posted 07 February 2013 - 10:01 PM

could be.. it was back in the late 70's, early 80's. he taught from 1949-the 80s, then retired. he was the chairman of the Life Science Dept at Los Angeles City College. i went there also back then :)




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users