Welcome to WhatBird Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Whatbird.com

Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

Last post 03-31-2008, 6:38 AM by MoJoWaxSwinger. 6 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  03-28-2008, 7:33 AM 29576

    Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

     

    I hope the pic comes up......I did everything I was told.

     

    If not, heres a description....

    I saw the bird in a clearing in the woods.  It seems bigger, at first....but it was probably between the size of a large sparrow and a small robin.  It was dark gray above, lighter gray (almost white) below.  His bill was shorter than the head, pointed and black.  Black legs and feet.  He had a semi-long tail that was the darkest part of the bird.  On the side of each wing is a very noticable white patch.....and when flying, the white in the birds wings becomes very obvious.....quite beautiful too.

     

    http://forum.grasscity.com/photopost/showphoto.php/photo/29662/ppuser/50675  This is the link where the bird is...in case it doesn't come up.


    Ya know what would be great for a guy like me?

    To be in a coma.

    -George Carlin-
  •  03-28-2008, 7:50 AM 29578 in reply to 29576

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

    Definately mockingbird.  Too large to be a gnatcatcher, and they dont hav the white wing bars.
  •  03-28-2008, 8:10 AM 29580 in reply to 29576

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

    the Blue-gray gnatcatcher has been described as a mini mockingbird but they are only about 4 inches long and rarely would you see them sitting still.  THey flit about among the leaves of trees searching for small bugs (gnats) just a fussin' all the while. 

    That white patch you see when the mockers fly is a dead give away

     


    Matthew 6:26
  •  03-28-2008, 8:44 AM 29584 in reply to 29580

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

    Also a mocker is longer than most robins, but slimmer. The tail is significantly longer. You def. have a beautiful mockingbird.

    "I put it down. you gotta pick it up." —Thelonious Monk
  •  03-28-2008, 8:51 AM 29588 in reply to 29584

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

    Don't forget about the song! BG Gnatcatchers make a little "zzz.zzz" as they fly around. A mocker would sing ( quite well!) or chirp loudly.

    I have to admit the first time I saw gnatcatchers, I thought " who shrunk the mockingbird?".

  •  03-28-2008, 9:23 AM 29605 in reply to 29576

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

     

     


    Don't cry because it's over, smile because you were there.
  •  03-31-2008, 6:38 AM 30163 in reply to 29605

    Re: Is this a blue-gray gnatcatcher or a mockingbird??

    At first I thought it wasn't a Mockingbird because the photo in my field guide....and online show a much meaner, more haggard looking bird.  Then I found a photo of a juvenile.....it might has well have been the bird I photographed.

     

    Thanks for the help.  I'm loading up some pics of a hawk I saw a few days ago.  Pretty sure it was a Cooper's.....it dove down and perched on a branch.....then attacked a finch on the ground near a feeder......sounds like everything I've heard about Cooper's.  Yet, my pictures look a lot like a Sharp-shinned......we'll see.


    Ya know what would be great for a guy like me?

    To be in a coma.

    -George Carlin-
View as RSS news feed in XML