Welcome to WhatBird Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Whatbird.com

Gray Catbird.........

Last post 05-30-2008, 6:07 PM by BonniePA. 16 replies.
Page 1 of 2 (17 items)   1 2 Next >
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  05-08-2008, 10:22 AM 36482

    Gray Catbird.........

    I saw this bird today around noon from my back porch in a condo complex.  I went inside to grab my camera and another one showed up.

     

    I was able to get fairly close before I learned the bird's boundaries.  In fact, it seemed rather interested in me as well.  It flipped its tail up towards the back of its head a lot....in addition to flicking it.

    I heard it make a call/song.....and I must say I didn't hear a cat meow-ing out of that.  Although I can see how some may think that.  One bird seemed to be the female...gathering material that one would assume is for a nest....  and another did the noise making and was much more brave.

     Gray Catbird (2).jpg

    These next photos are the other individual.....

    Gray Catbird.jpg

    Gray Catbird (showing rusty vent).jpg

     

    Am I correct in identifying this bird as a Gray Catbird??  Also, is the top one a female and bottom male??  The one on top is a beutiful bird....better looking than the other for sure.

     


    Total ('08 and Life): 161

    Most recent: Mourning Warbler, Canada Warbler, Philadelphia and Blue-headed Vireos, Yellow-Bellied Sapsucker

    Favs: Indigo Bunting, Cerulean Warbler, Broad-winged Hawk, Pileated Woodpecker, Canada Warbler
  •  05-08-2008, 10:25 AM 36483 in reply to 36482

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    I agree with Catbird. Males and Females are indistinguishable in the field.

    2008 Yard List: 118
    Recent: Hooded Warbler, Black-billed Cuckoo
    Highlights: Hoary Redpoll, Golden Eagle, Fish Crow
    2008 Year List: 181
    Recent: Alder Flycatcher, Green Heron
    Highlights: Cackling Goose, Black Vulture, Merlin

  •  05-08-2008, 12:28 PM 36507 in reply to 36483

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Absolutely both catbirds. No sexual dimporphism as cnybirder notes.

    "I put it down. you gotta pick it up." —Thelonious Monk
  •  05-08-2008, 12:54 PM 36511 in reply to 36507

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    I must agree with the first two!!  Nice shots!
  •  05-08-2008, 1:05 PM 36513 in reply to 36482

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Definitely a Gray catbird.
  •  05-08-2008, 1:31 PM 36519 in reply to 36513

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Definitely already ID'd as a Catbird, definitely.
    Dan Kopp
    Sacramento

    Many dreams come true, and some have silver linings; I live for my dream and a pocketful of gold...
  •  05-09-2008, 7:11 AM 36673 in reply to 36519

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Great pics. Ive recently Id this pretty bird in my yard. They come very close to me while in the garden - their even more beautiful close up. Enjoy them!
    Happy Birding!
  •  05-09-2008, 7:50 AM 36698 in reply to 36673

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Once I heard their 'cat' (doesn't really sound like a cat.... I have 5) call, I was able to imitate it well enough that they would quickly jump to an opening to see what was up.  They are very curious birds......  just like their relative the Northern Mockingbird.  Don't they look a lot alike??  Obviously not colors, but tail shape, size, bill, overall body shape..and demeanor.

     

    That first picture of the Catbird in the tree is one of my favorite shots I've taken all year.  I don't mean to be snotty/concieded, but that pic looks better than all the ones in my field guides.  Granted I touched it up a little in Adobe.... the photo still makes a cool bird look gorgeous.  Perhaps the contrasting green around him/her helps.....

     

    I think/hope that the pair has moved in to my woods.  The one that I pretended was the female (first pic, in the tree) was silent while gathering random materials...while the one I pretended to be the male stayed on neighborhood watch.  He didn't exactly follow me, more so keeping tabs on me.  Their song (not call) is quite pleasing to the ears and I would enjoy their continued presence.


    Total ('08 and Life): 161

    Most recent: Mourning Warbler, Canada Warbler, Philadelphia and Blue-headed Vireos, Yellow-Bellied Sapsucker

    Favs: Indigo Bunting, Cerulean Warbler, Broad-winged Hawk, Pileated Woodpecker, Canada Warbler
  •  05-09-2008, 7:58 AM 36704 in reply to 36698

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    I finally had a lot of time to spend listening to them lastnight. I dont think they really sound like a cat either (I have 4), sometimes like a baby though. Now I know their sound which is very distinct.

    It took me awhile to ID this bird because my guide's pic of the bird looked entirley black - and you couldnt see the black stripe on its head. I finally found a perfect likeness through the whatbird guide. (It was the first time my book had a bad pic but did make me realize I may need to use other guides than just my handy dandy pocket guide.)


    Happy Birding!
  •  05-12-2008, 7:05 AM 37325 in reply to 36704

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Since my last post I've discovered where the (now three) Catbirds live/hang-out in the woods behind my house.  First things first..... Bonnie was right, they should be called 'Annoying baby sounding-birds'.

     

    I often wander for hours and get lost in the natural beauty of a New England forest..... I am lucky enough to live in the middle of one.  The section of woods behind my house is probably about a square mile, although not a square shape.  It is made up primarily of mixed deciduous trees, with some evergreens thrown into the mix.....usually in bunches.  And those bunches are usually Eastern Red Pine.

     

    Yesterday, like many times before, I was slowly cruising though the woods and getting lost in all the warblers, thrushes, woodpeckers (I finally saw the male Hairy I've been looking for), Chipping, Savannah and White-Throated Sparrows, wild turkeys, the resident Red-tail Hawk family, the resident Vulture family, the resident Kestrel family...and a few random others such as thrashers.  Every direction I look I see something....if not birds, it could be a Black Rat, Garter or Norther Ring-necked snakes....Dusky, Red-backed or Spotted Salamanders...maybe a newt or two.....peeper frogs and Woodhouse toads....White-tailed deer, chipmonks galore, squirrels feeding their babies (which proves they have food other than my feeders)...and the less popular red fox, coyote and woodchuck...

     ....after walking for about an hour, I started hearing the pretty warbler-like call, soon followed by the cry.  I had stumbled upon the Catbirds area.  It happened to be in one of the coolest parts of my woods.... there is a small valley/rift that starts half-way in the woods and runs to the end.  On the borders of the valley are tall deciduous trees, flowering dogwoods, and my favorite...Pink Azaleas.  Inside the valley there is a lot of bramble and other thron bushes, and a lot of small bushes that all come together to make a fairly dense thicket.  Running through the center, and I assume what created the valley over several decades, is a small (crystal clear) brook that is 4 feet at it's widest.  On the 'shore' of the brook are lots of skunk cabbage and ferns, gorgeous beds of common violets (one has to be 20 feet square), a few wild geraniums thrown in, and a bunch of other wildflowers.  Criss-crossing the whole area are downed trees and limbs that give shelter to many insects, amphibians, reptiles (about 5 years ago I spotted the lone CT lizard in this spot....the Five-Lined Skink), and chipmunks.  When the larger trees fall their roots often stay somewhat connected to the ground while the tree is horizontal....over time the roots become covered over and the hole left fills with water....this is where I often find Spotted, Box and Wodd turtles.

    The location and elevation of the woods prevents the trees from growing much higher than 60 feet.  Although my area is considered forest, it is still a 15 minutes drive from Long Island Sound.  Strong winds and weather are the norm throughout the year, causing tall/weak trees to fall....which is beneficial to the woods.  The fallen limbs/trees create habitats for many different animals...in addition to making natural bridges to cross the brook, streams and swamps.  The opening in the canopy left by the fallen tree allows sunlight to hit the ground where it normally doesn't, giving energy to new saplings that will grow tall and start the cycle all over again.

     

    In this location I just described, the Catbirds were completely at ease.  One or two would forage and bring back nest material while one would 'stand watch' and sing the warbler-like song.  They often rotated.  They seemed to really enjoy hopping along downed tree trunks..... I think the highest I saw any of them in a tree was (maybe) 10 feet up.  They always were either on a branch, logs, or rock that was as close to the ground as they could get without actually being on the ground.

    Once I found this spot (which was filled with Black and White, Blue-winged and Black-throated Blue Warblers.....wood and hermit thrushes and veerys.....and a zillion chipmunks) I decided to have lunch and sit and let nature come to me.  And come to me it did....  one of the Catbirds got so close that I was going over in my head whether or not I should try to catch him...while I was sitting down.  I decided to leave him be...which was the right decision.  For leaving him be, he allowed me to have a conversation with him.  I would make three 'pishing/whistle' noises....and he would respond with a little bit of his warbler-like call.  We did this for about 15 minutes before six deer came barreling through the woods..... I soon found out that a homeowner had their dog escape, as it too flew past me on the trail of the deer.

    Once the deer ruind the moment I continued back on my aimless wandering..... and the Catbird came with me.  He followed me for a good two hours..... all the while doing his own business, but following me nonetheless.  He always stayed at a minimum distance of about 12 feet...unless I stopped and sat for 15+ minutes....then he would come very close.  A few times he was within my reach.

     

     

    I do not know why I described the whole forest, I suppose I wanted to create a decent visualization of the habitat.  I have really grown fond of the Catbirds...  they are very pretty birds, and in the right light witht heir tail fanned a little bit....they are gorgeous.  I especially enjoy their calm, curious demeanor....  it allows me to get really close and learn about them.   I have yet to pinpoint the nest, but hope do to so soon.  I made a crappy map of my forest and mark off where I see nests so I can keep an eye on them.  Right now I know the nest location of Red-bellied Woodpeckers, Downy Woodpeckers, a Northern Flicker, White-throated Sparrows and Chipping Sparrows,  American Goldfinches,  a pair of Indigo Buntings, Red-tailed Hawks and an American Woodcock.  I would like to add the Catbird's nest on my list.....  when I go into the forest I make rounds and check each nesting spot.....  so far I've seen some babies that are as ugly as they are cute.  Although not all of the nests have babies/eggs (I can't see some).

     

    So I guess the moral of the rant is that I like Gray Catbirds. =)


    Total ('08 and Life): 161

    Most recent: Mourning Warbler, Canada Warbler, Philadelphia and Blue-headed Vireos, Yellow-Bellied Sapsucker

    Favs: Indigo Bunting, Cerulean Warbler, Broad-winged Hawk, Pileated Woodpecker, Canada Warbler
  •  05-16-2008, 7:02 AM 38439 in reply to 37325

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    WOW Iam impressed by your post and descriptions! My first thought was "road trip" - your area sounds wonderful and you seem to know it so well!

    Enjoy all of it - you've been given a wonderful gift!!!


    Happy Birding!
  •  05-23-2008, 10:36 AM 39732 in reply to 36482

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Did this bird sound it was saying "Larry"? I am having trouble myself identifying this bird as well, that's if it makes the sounds I heard.
  •  05-24-2008, 12:27 PM 39990 in reply to 39732

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    bazookajoe:
    Did this bird sound it was saying "Larry"? I am having trouble myself identifying this bird as well, that's if it makes the sounds I heard.

    LOL...see now I hear it saying " Mary Mary Mary", which is my name. And how sweet with how the catbird calls my name, hehe. Here "kitty kitty!!!!

    I actually like the catbird song...all parts of it that I have heard and it makes me smile.

    I happy that a catbird has recently been attending my "birdfeeder roof".  It eats the seed but I think a few peach and apple chunks invited it there in the first place. Now I hear it saying " Yummy Yummy Yummy".

    You are welcome lil catbird...... 

     


    * laughs like crow, soars like eagle with vision of hawk, haunts like loon & lulls like nuthatch ....tickle tickle, feather has most powerful medicine of all...makes you laugh *
  •  05-28-2008, 5:50 PM 41047 in reply to 39990

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    Now that I've noticed these birds they seem to be everywhereSmile Which is OK with me I love watching them. They really do get close to me when Im in the garden or sitting outside. I actually saw one chase a woodpecker from a suet feeder yest. which I thought was interesting. I havent gotten them to take to any fruit yet but Ill keep trying.
    Happy Birding!
  •  05-28-2008, 7:05 PM 41088 in reply to 36482

    Re: Gray Catbird.........

    I saw your wonderful pictures and thought you might appreciate this one ... Cat birds do look a lot like Mockingbirds but are no where near as loud.  I'm a little jealous that you got to hear yours sing.  "A cat seemed to have this one's tongue" because I never heard a peep.  I do hope that I see it again, but so far I haven't.

    BJ
Page 1 of 2 (17 items)   1 2 Next >
View as RSS news feed in XML