Welcome to WhatBird Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Whatbird.com

Sparrow?

Last post 05-14-2008, 2:03 PM by barredowl. 10 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  05-13-2008, 6:01 PM 37790

    Sparrow?

    This was taken tonight @ Ponemah Bog Wildlife Sanctuary in Amherst, NH.   please help me ID this?

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/rdatkins/2491162546/

  •  05-13-2008, 6:36 PM 37805 in reply to 37790

    Re: Sparrow?

    Can't really see the rump, but I'd guess fox sparrow. Maybe a song sparrow?
    Don't cry because it's over, smile because you were there.
  •  05-13-2008, 6:45 PM 37810 in reply to 37790

    Re: Sparrow?

    I'm not good at ID'ing sparrows but I'll guess a song sparrow
    Matthew 6:26
  •  05-13-2008, 7:09 PM 37819 in reply to 37810

    Re: Sparrow?

    Song Sparrow.
    Warbler Life List: 35 species
    Sparrow Life List: 18 species
    Owl Life List: 9 species
  •  05-13-2008, 7:59 PM 37846 in reply to 37790

    Re: Sparrow?

    Savannah Sparrow gets my vote.  The breast pattern is wrong for Song Sparrow. Here's a Song Sparrow showing its nice dark breast spot:

     


  •  05-13-2008, 9:50 PM 37872 in reply to 37846

    Re: Sparrow?

    Wouldn't the savannah sparrow have some yellow above the eye?

  •  05-13-2008, 10:18 PM 37879 in reply to 37872

    Re: Sparrow?

    I was wondering about that. Doesn't it look like this one has a little yellow behind its eye?
    Chris from Denver
  •  05-14-2008, 6:55 AM 37906 in reply to 37879

    Re: Sparrow?

    Not a Savannah.  Song Sparrows don't all show such defined breast spots.  If it isn't a Song (which I think it is), maybe a Lincol's??  Looks too big, but I always confuse Lincolns for Songs without the breast spot.
    **MoJo's Warbler Watch** --> 21 species; Most recent-> Worm-eating Warbler (7/12)

    **2008/Life Total** --> 169 species;
    Most recent-> Laughing Gull (8/19), Clapper Rail (8/19
  •  05-14-2008, 8:01 AM 37928 in reply to 37906

    Re: Sparrow?

    Having seen a few lately, my first guess was Lincoln's.
  •  05-14-2008, 8:01 AM 37929 in reply to 37906

    Re: Sparrow?

    This is definitely a Song Sparrow.

    EDIT: I will explain my reasoning.

    I would expect Savannah to have a white crown stripe, yellow supercillium behind the eye, overall lighter coloration with crisper streaks on the breast and crown and fewer breast streaks. I would also expect it to have a lighter, cleaner breast than this bird, which is a grayish, dirtier looking breast typical of Song. The bill is also pretty dark on this bird, suggesting Song.

    I would expect Lincoln's to have a buffy malar, grayish face above the eye, very very crisp breast streaks, with buffy wash across the breast and down the sides. This bird shows none of those field marks.


    Warbler Life List: 35 species
    Sparrow Life List: 18 species
    Owl Life List: 9 species
  •  05-14-2008, 2:03 PM 38047 in reply to 37790

    Re: Sparrow?

    I agree with Song sparrow.
View as RSS news feed in XML