Welcome to WhatBird Forums Sign in | Join | Help
in Search

Whatbird.com

Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

Last post 08-31-2009, 6:50 AM by sixteenvalleybirds. 13 replies.
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  05-07-2009, 6:27 PM 93283

    Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Attachment: yellow 004.jpg
    We've had Rose-breasted Grosbeaks (several males and at least one female) passing through our yard for the past week or so.  Today, this guy showed up.  None of our field guides mention anything about a colour variation for these birds.  Has anyone seen this before?
  •  05-07-2009, 6:49 PM 93304 in reply to 93283

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    sixteenvalleybirds:
    Has anyone seen this before?

    No (well not me)!  But this kind of variation is known in other species.  For example, male House Finches, which are normally red on the head and breast, rarely are yellow instead.  I've read this may have to do with diet.  Anyway, this is really cool.  You might want to send this picture to the Cornell Lab of Ornithology - they would probably appreciate the record.  contact info here: http://www.birds.cornell.edu/About/HowToReachUs.html


    Randy
  •  05-07-2009, 7:35 PM 93315 in reply to 93283

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    I don't have any useful information to add to what Randy said, but that's really cool! Thanks for sharing! :D
  •  05-07-2009, 8:01 PM 93324 in reply to 93283

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    That's extraordinary - great picture, thanks for sharing.
  •  05-07-2009, 8:08 PM 93327 in reply to 93324

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Nice find and shot. I have never heard of color variation in RB Grosbeaks but apparently it exists!Big Smile Thanks for posting.
    Life list: 291
    Latest: Brown-headed Nuthatch, Swallow-Tailed Kite, Marbled Godwit.
  •  05-07-2009, 9:23 PM 93334 in reply to 93283

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    I love the Internet! Here is an article I found on this beautiful bird.

    Rose-breasted Grosbeak, memory

    Answers to readers' questions about xanthochroism, spatial memory, and site fidelity
    By Julie Craves
    Published: Friday, June 20, 2003
    A Rose-breasted Grosbeak with yellow instead of red on its breast has come to my feeder for the last five summers. Is the bird a hybrid? - John Smith, Howell, Michigan

    This very interesting bird is not a hybrid, as you suspect, but a Rose-breasted Grosbeak with a condition called xanthochroism. Xanthochroism is a pigment disorder, as are albinism (lack of pigment) and melanism (excess pigment). In xanthochroistic birds, either there is excessive yellow pigment in the feathers or yellow replaces another color, typically red. Xanthochroism occurs not only in birds, but also in other organisms. It may be caused by dietary deficiencies or a genetic mutation.

    While fairly rare, the condition is nonetheless reported in a number of species of birds. One in which it is noted nearly annually is the Red-bellied Woodpecker. Because the red color of the head is replaced by a golden yellow, the Red-bellieds are often misidentified as Golden-fronted Woodpeckers. Orange Scarlet Tanagers and Northern Cardinals are also fairly common. I keep a large file on birds with "pigment problems," and yours is the first Rose-breasted Grosbeak I've come across.
  •  05-07-2009, 9:25 PM 93335 in reply to 93327

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Attachment: rb.jpg

    Something seems a bit off to me in that photo. Wouldn't you think the black neck feathers would run into the yellow more like this?

     


  •  05-08-2009, 1:52 PM 93454 in reply to 93335

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    billkaye:

    Something seems a bit off to me in that photo. Wouldn't you think the black neck feathers would run into the yellow more like this?

     

    They do.  Or am I missing something?

    Very cool bird sixteenvalleybird.

    Scott

  •  05-08-2009, 6:19 PM 93520 in reply to 93454

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Thanks, everyone.  We've sent an email to the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, and we'll update everyone if we get a response.  We saw him yesterday in the early afternoon, and again in the evening, but we didn't see him again today.  Hopefully he'll be back tomorrow!
  •  05-12-2009, 9:39 AM 94316 in reply to 93520

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Here's the reply we received from Cornell:

     Dear ,
          That's a great shot!  The red in the Rose-breasted Grosbeak's breast is under the control of carotenoid pigments.  When there's too little of a specific pigment the red becomes orange.  If there's even less, it becomes yellow.   Sometimes we see a bird that is missing the pigment in a part of its feathers, a white-headed robins or perhaps a crow with a large white patch on its wing.  Sometimes a bird just has a little too much or a little too little pigmentation in its feathers and occasionally birds are missing all pigmentation, albino birds.  There are a number of causes of such lack of pigmentation.  You can read more about birds at our All About Birds web site at http://www.birds.cornell.edu/AllAboutBirds/attracting/challenges/strange_birds/ .

     Anne Hobbs
    Public Information Specialist
    Cornell Lab of Ornithology
    http://www.birds.cornell.edu

  •  06-05-2009, 4:11 PM 99221 in reply to 94316

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Thanks for the info! Just today I had a grosbeak with a yellow breast like yours come to my feeder. I wasn't able to get a picture, but perhaps he'll give me another chance. At any rate, I'm glad to know what's going on with him!
  •  06-05-2009, 6:53 PM 99259 in reply to 99221

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    Beautiful shot, sixteenvalleybirds. Whereabouts in southern Ontario are you located? Just curious/doubtfully hopefull, that I might happen upon him in my travels around the area of Acton/Milton/Georgetown.

    My unorganized pictures can be viewed at

    http://picasaweb.google.com/lonestranger102
  •  06-06-2009, 5:02 PM 99398 in reply to 99221

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    LauraBean:
    Thanks for the info! Just today I had a grosbeak with a yellow breast like yours come to my feeder. I wasn't able to get a picture, but perhaps he'll give me another chance. At any rate, I'm glad to know what's going on with him!

     

    I also found the following statement Online from a birder in WI.

    delores
    02-Jun-2008 15:59
    Have you ever seen a rose breasted grosbeak with a yellow breast rather than the red breast?? We have one at our feeder and it looks exactly like the rose breasted but it is yellow breasted??
    We are located in northwest Wisconsin.. We have been bird feeding for 30 years and this is a first...

     


    http://whatbird.com/forums/photos/birdman/
  •  08-31-2009, 6:50 AM 113758 in reply to 99259

    Re: Yellow-breasted Grosbeak?

    We're in Oakville, just on the Milton/Oakville border.  Unfortunately we didn't see him again. 
View as RSS news feed in XML